Pick your first Japanese mystery novel by asking what you do when an Agatha Christie book gets good. If you stop to work out how anyone could have left the room, start with The Honjin Murders. If you keep a running list of suspects, pick The Decagon House Murders. If the ending sends you back to reread the opening chapters, try The Devotion of Suspect X.
All three are available in English translation, and you can read any of them first. This guide keeps the solutions under wraps.
| What you love about Christie | Read this first | What you’ll be trying to figure out |
|---|---|---|
| A locked-room puzzle | The Honjin Murders by Seishi Yokomizo | How could anyone commit the crime and get away? |
| A small circle of suspects | The Decagon House Murders by Yukito Ayatsuji | Which member of the group could be responsible? |
| A reveal that changes earlier scenes | The Devotion of Suspect X by Keigo Higashino | How much of the crime did you really understand when you saw it happen? |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
If you want a locked-room puzzle, start with The Honjin Murders

In a Japanese village in 1937, a scream and the sound of a stringed instrument wake the Ichiyanagi household. The bride and groom are found dead on their wedding night. The room was locked from the inside, and a bloodied sword stands in the snow. Detective Kosuke Kindaichi has to explain how the scene could exist in the first place.
This is the book to pick if you like pausing over the physical evidence in a Poirot novel. The lock is one part of the puzzle. The snow gives you a way to think about where someone could have walked, and the music makes you ask what the household could actually tell from what they heard. Before the killer’s identity can make sense, you need a version of the night that accounts for all those details at once.
Choose Louise Heal Kawai’s English translation. See the paperback or read our review of The Honjin Murders.
If you want a small circle of suspects, start with The Decagon House Murders

Seven university mystery club members spend a week in a ten-sided house on an island where several people died months earlier. When a member of the group turns up dead, the survivors have good reason to suspect one another. Meanwhile, an unsettling letter starts a separate inquiry on the mainland.
If And Then There Were None is your favorite Christie, this is the closest match of the three. Ayatsuji gives you a cast who already know the rules of a setup like this. They read detective fiction and can see what the island is doing to their odds of survival. Knowing the conventions gives them plenty of theories about one another. The mainland chapters give you another line of inquiry to follow while the group on the island tries to make sense of the latest death.
Our spoiler-free review of The Decagon House Murders goes into what makes those two strands work together. Ho-Ling Wong translated the English edition.
The Decagon House Murders in paperback on Amazon
If you want a reveal that changes the whole book, start with The Devotion of Suspect X

Higashino puts the crime near the beginning. Yasuko Hanaoka’s abusive ex-husband turns up at her apartment and ends up dead after a confrontation. Her neighbor Ishigami, a mathematics teacher, offers to help cover it up. When a detective can’t find a hole in Yasuko’s alibi, he turns to physicist Manabu Yukawa for help. Yukawa and Ishigami know each other from college.
Think of the impulse to turn back to chapter one after finishing The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Higashino gets you there by giving you enough early information to feel as though you’re ahead of the police. As Yukawa looks harder at the case, you start to question how much that head start was worth. The reveal also changes how you read Ishigami’s offer to help. An act that seemed easy to explain when he made it looks different once you understand its cost.
Look for the English translation by Alexander O. Smith with Elye J. Alexander. You can also read our review of The Devotion of Suspect X.
Find The Devotion of Suspect X in paperback on Amazon
Still deciding? I’d hand most Christie fans The Decagon House Murders first. You’ll recognize the setup from the moment the group arrives, which gives you an immediate way into Ayatsuji’s puzzle. Save The Honjin Murders for when you want to draw the crime scene on a scrap of paper and The Devotion of Suspect X for when you want the last chapter to send you back to the first.
For more from Christie herself, see five Agatha Christie mysteries and how to choose between them.
Follow us on Instagram and Facebook
Discover more from Books of Brilliance
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.





