Spoiler warning: This recap reveals the ending of Gideon the Ninth and stops at the end of Book 1.
The two details worth remembering before you start Harrow the Ninth are easy to mix up. Dulcinea Septimus was already dead when the trials began, and Gideon Nav’s body is missing by the time Harrow wakes aboard the Emperor’s ship. In between, Harrow becomes a Lyctor, Ianthe survives the fight at Canaan House, and the Emperor has no answers about several of the people Harrow last saw alive.
If you remember the skeletons and the sword fights but have lost track of which House everyone came from, here’s how the murders, the trials, and Gideon’s final decision fit together.
Why did Gideon and Harrow go to Canaan House?
Gideon Nav wants to escape the Ninth House and join the Cohort. Harrowhark Nonagesimus, the Ninth’s necromancer and heir, needs a cavalier to answer the Emperor’s summons. When Harrow’s original cavalier, Ortus Nigenad, flees with his mother, Gideon takes his place in exchange for the chance to earn her freedom.
At Canaan House, the sprawling First House estate, the priest Teacher oversees the heirs and their cavaliers as they investigate how the Emperor’s original Lyctors gained their power. The old laboratories hold pieces of the method. One trial has Harrow use Gideon’s senses to study a regenerating bone construct while Gideon fights it. Another requires Harrow to draw on Gideon’s life force. Both put the cavalier at risk, and both give the pair practice doing what the final process will demand on a much more intimate scale.
Who was behind the Canaan House murders?
The first deaths the guests discover are Abigail Pent and Magnus Quinn, the married Fifth House pair. Gideon and Harrow find them dead at the bottom of a shaft after the anniversary dinner. Later, a regenerating bone construct kills Isaac Tettares of the Fourth House. Gideon tries to get his cavalier, Jeannemary Chatur, to safety, but Jeannemary is killed too.
The woman Gideon knows as Dulcinea Septimus is Cytherea the First, one of the Emperor’s original Lyctors. She killed the real Dulcinea and her cavalier, Protesilaus Ebdoma, before the trials, then impersonated Dulcinea and animated Protesilaus’s corpse. Harrow’s discovery that Protesilaus was already dead when he arrived gives the Ninth a clue that the Seventh House delegation was a deception from the start.
The Sixth House necromancer Palamedes Sextus had corresponded with the real Dulcinea for years. He exposes Cytherea, who has been sabotaging the trials to prevent the creation of more Lyctors and wants to kill the Emperor. Palamedes accelerates the cancer she has kept in check and then blows himself up. Cytherea survives the explosion, but the damage he does to her matters in the final fight.
Other deaths come out of the contestants’ own choices. Teacher and the First House priests die in a confrontation with the Second House, which also leaves the cavalier Marta Dyas dead and Captain Judith Deuteros gravely wounded. Judith manages to send a distress signal that reaches the Emperor.
How does Ianthe become a Lyctor?
Ianthe Tridentarius kills her cavalier, Naberius Tern, and takes his soul into herself. The process gives her a source of necromantic power and access to his combat skills. It also exposes the secret Ianthe and her twin, Coronabeth, have been keeping: Ianthe is the Third House’s only necromancer. Coronabeth has been passing as one with her sister’s help.
Silas Octakiseron tries to stop Ianthe by siphoning his own cavalier, Colum Asht. Something takes possession of Colum’s body and kills Silas, and Ianthe kills the possessed Colum. Silas condemns what Ianthe did to Naberius, then drains Colum against his wishes.
What does Harrow tell Gideon in the pool?
Before the final fight, Harrow tells Gideon why nearly an entire generation of Ninth House children died. Harrow’s parents killed two hundred children to supply the necromantic energy needed to conceive her. Gideon was exposed to the same poison and somehow survived.
Harrow also tells Gideon that she opened the Locked Tomb as a child and saw a girl lying inside. Her parents took their own lives after learning what she had done. Gideon has spent years blaming herself for telling them about Harrow’s break-in. In the pool, she learns how much Harrow has been carrying, and the two finally talk about the history they’ve used against each other since childhood.
The confession changes the terms of their partnership. When the novel begins, walking away from Harrow is what freedom looks like to Gideon. By the time Cytherea corners them, Gideon has to decide what she’s willing to give up to keep Harrow alive.
What happens to Gideon at the end?
Cytherea overpowers Gideon, Harrow, and Camilla Hect, Palamedes’s cavalier. Ianthe intervenes and loses an arm. Harrow shelters Gideon and Camilla behind a barrier of bone, but she’s running out of strength. Gideon offers Harrow her soul. Harrow refuses.
Gideon throws herself onto the iron spikes so Harrow can become a Lyctor and defeat Cytherea. Harrow takes in Gideon’s soul, and for a short time Gideon can still speak to her and guide her swordsmanship. With Gideon’s help, Harrow exploits the damage Palamedes inflicted and kills Cytherea. She then retrieves Gideon’s body from the spikes.
Ianthe and Harrow reach Lyctorhood through the same process, and the difference is who makes the choice. Ianthe decides what Naberius will give up. Gideon makes that decision herself, leaving Harrow with a power she was willing to die without.
What to remember before Harrow the Ninth
Harrow wakes on the Emperor’s flagship. She asks him to bring Gideon back, and he says he can’t separate their souls without destroying Gideon’s soul and killing Harrow. Harrow agrees to serve him. Here’s where the rest of the cast stands at the end of Book 1:
| Who | What Book 1 establishes |
|---|---|
| Harrowhark Nonagesimus | Survives and joins the Emperor as a Lyctor. |
| Gideon Nav | Dies at Canaan House. Harrow takes in her soul, and the Emperor reports that her body is missing. |
| Ianthe Tridentarius | Survives as a Lyctor after absorbing Naberius’s soul. |
| Camilla Hect, Coronabeth Tridentarius, and Judith Deuteros | Unaccounted for when Harrow speaks to the Emperor. |
| Palamedes Sextus | Dies in the blast he sets off against Cytherea. |
| Cytherea the First | Dies at Harrow’s hand. The real Dulcinea died before the trials. |
Keep that last scene in mind if Harrow the Ninth gives you a different account of Canaan House. Book 1 ends with Harrow asking for Gideon back and learning that Gideon’s body has disappeared.
For more on how Muir builds the mystery, read our Gideon the Ninth review. You’ll also find Harrow the Ninth in our science fantasy recommendations.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir, Tor Books trade paperback
- Harrow the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir, Tor Books trade paperback
Follow us on Instagram and Facebook
Discover more from Books of Brilliance
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.





