The Terror Book Review: Dan Simmons’ Chilling Franklin Expedition Novel

ConclusionFew stories are as unsettling as real historical mysteries, especially when an author takes the unanswered questions surrounding a famous disaster and imagines something even more terrifying.

Dan Simmons does exactly that in The Terror, a historical horror novel inspired by the doomed Franklin expedition. Originally published in 2007, the novel combines Arctic survival, historical fiction, supernatural horror, and mystery into an unforgettable story about two ships trapped in one of the most hostile environments on Earth.

Even knowing the history behind the expedition does little to prepare you for where Simmons takes the story.

Here is our review of The Terror by Dan Simmons and whether this chilling historical novel deserves a spot on your reading list.

The Terror Summary

In 1845, HMS Erebus and HMS Terror embark on an expedition into the Arctic in search of the Northwest Passage.

But the expedition quickly turns into a nightmare.

The two ships become trapped in the ice, leaving their crews stranded hundreds of miles from civilization. More than a year passes, and the situation continues to deteriorate.

Temperatures are brutally cold. Food supplies are running low. Much of the remaining canned food is questionable, and there is almost nothing available to hunt.

Escaping on foot may eventually become the crew’s only option.

Unfortunately, starvation and freezing temperatures aren’t their only problems.

Something appears to be hunting them.

Crew members begin dying after encounters with a mysterious creature lurking beyond the ships. It resembles an enormous polar bear, but its behavior suggests something far stranger. The creature seems intelligent, calculating, and almost impossible to kill.

As the attacks become more frequent, the sailors aboard Terror and Erebus struggle to understand exactly what they are facing.

But fear of the creature is only part of their growing nightmare.

Illness, dwindling supplies, brutal weather, desperation, and conflict among the surviving men slowly threaten to destroy the expedition from within.

Eventually, the crew must decide whether remaining aboard their frozen ships gives them their best chance of survival—or whether they should abandon them and attempt the dangerous journey across the Arctic.

Either choice could mean death.

And somewhere beyond the ships, something is waiting for them.

The True Story Behind The Terror

One of the reasons The Terror works so well is because its fictional story is built around a very real historical mystery.

Sir John Franklin’s expedition departed England in 1845 aboard HMS Erebus and HMS Terror. Its goal was to navigate one of the remaining unexplored portions of the Northwest Passage through the Canadian Arctic.

The expedition never returned.

All 129 men ultimately disappeared or died.

Over the following decades, numerous expeditions searched for Franklin and his crew. Evidence gradually revealed pieces of what happened, including that the ships had become trapped in ice and that the surviving members eventually abandoned them.

But many questions remained unanswered.

That uncertainty gives Simmons plenty of room to imagine what might have happened during those horrifying years in the Arctic.

There is also an interesting real-world development that occurred after the novel was published.

Simmons released The Terror in 2007, when neither ship had been located. HMS Erebus was finally discovered in 2014, followed by HMS Terror in 2016.

Those discoveries have helped researchers learn more about Franklin’s doomed expedition, but they haven’t eliminated all of the mystery surrounding the crew’s final months.

And, fortunately for horror readers, the explanation Simmons creates is far more frightening than anything historians are likely to discover.

Historical Fiction Meets Supernatural Horror

Turning the Franklin expedition into a horror novel was a brilliant decision.

Simmons doesn’t need the supernatural elements to make the story frightening. Being stranded in the Arctic during the nineteenth century is terrifying enough.

The cold alone could kill you.

Then there is starvation, disease, contaminated food, isolation, and the realization that rescue may never arrive.

Simmons takes all of those real dangers and adds another threat: an enormous creature stalking the men through the ice.

That combination makes The Terror feel different from most horror novels.

The characters aren’t simply trapped inside a haunted house or fleeing a monster. They’re trapped in an enormous frozen wilderness where practically everything around them can kill them.

Even if they defeat the creature, they still have to survive the Arctic.

Dan Simmons Creates an Incredible Sense of Dread

What I enjoyed most about The Terror is the atmosphere.

Simmons makes the Arctic feel unbelievably hostile.

The darkness, freezing temperatures, endless ice, and isolation create a constant sense of dread. You can almost feel how hopeless the situation becomes as supplies disappear and the crew realizes just how far they are from safety.

And then the creature appears.

Simmons wisely doesn’t rely entirely on the monster to generate suspense. Some of the most disturbing moments come from watching what desperation does to people.

As conditions worsen, relationships begin breaking down.

Fear turns into anger.

Leadership becomes increasingly difficult.

Survival starts overriding morality.

The men aren’t simply fighting against something supernatural. They’re fighting against nature and, eventually, one another.

That makes the novel much more compelling than a straightforward monster story.

The Terror Is a Slow-Burn Horror Novel

Readers should know that The Terror is a long book.

Simmons spends a significant amount of time developing the characters, explaining life aboard the ships, exploring nineteenth-century naval culture, and recreating the conditions of an Arctic expedition.

That level of detail won’t appeal to everyone.

If you’re looking for a short horror novel filled with nonstop monster attacks, this probably isn’t the book for you.

But the slower pacing serves a purpose.

Simmons gradually makes the situation worse until the crew and the reader begins to feel trapped.

The length also allows the characters to become much more than historical names. Their personalities, rivalries, fears, ambitions, and weaknesses become important parts of the story.

By the time things truly begin falling apart, you’ve spent enough time with these people to care about what happens to them.

A Story That Stayed With Me

One of the biggest compliments I can give a novel is that I continue thinking about it months after finishing it.

The Terror is one of those books.

I love novels that take unexplained moments from history and imagine what might have happened. Simmons had an incredible historical mystery to work with, and his supernatural explanation makes the Franklin expedition even more haunting.

It is also difficult to predict exactly where a Dan Simmons novel is going.

Every time I thought I understood the type of story I was reading, Simmons seemed willing to take it somewhere unexpected.

That unpredictability is one of the reasons I continue returning to his work.

Should You Read The Terror by Dan Simmons?

I definitely recommend The Terror, especially if you enjoy books that blend genres.

Readers who love historical fiction will appreciate the detail surrounding the Franklin expedition and nineteenth-century Arctic exploration.

Horror fans will enjoy the supernatural threat and increasingly disturbing atmosphere.

And readers who enjoy survival stories will find plenty to love as the expedition slowly descends into chaos.

You should consider reading The Terror if you enjoy:

• Historical horror
• Survival fiction
• Arctic exploration stories
• Slow-burn suspense
• Supernatural mysteries
• Large casts of characters
• Fiction inspired by real events

The novel is lengthy, and some readers may find its historical detail demanding. But if you enjoy immersive books that take their time building atmosphere, that patience is rewarded.

The Terror by Dan Simmons Review: Final Thoughts

Dan Simmons has written some of my favorite books, and The Terror lived up to my expectations.

Taking the mysterious disappearance of the Franklin expedition and transforming it into a supernatural horror novel was an inspired idea. But the monster isn’t what makes the book truly frightening.

The cold, starvation, isolation, disease, desperation, and breakdown of order are often just as terrifying.

Simmons is an excellent storyteller who knows how to slowly pull readers deeper into a story until it becomes difficult to put the book down.

Even if you already know the history of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror, there are plenty of surprises waiting for you here.

The Terror is haunting, immersive, and memorable—and easily one of the most fascinating historical horror novels I’ve read.

Rating: 4.5/5

If you’re looking for a sprawling survival story that combines history with supernatural horror, The Terror is absolutely worth reading

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook