The Raven Scholar was one of my favorite fantasy reads of the year. The murder mystery pulled me in. The question I kept coming back to was what Neema Kraa owes the empire that gave her a place at court. Her work as High Scholar has taught her how power operates in Orrun. It has also given her reasons to look away.

These 18 The Raven Scholar book club questions explore Neema’s choices, the loyalties that survive the succession trials, and what would actually make someone fit to rule Orrun. The first three questions are safe for readers who are still making their way through Antonia Hodgson’s novel.

If your group is deciding whether to read it, start with my spoiler-free review of The Raven Scholar.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Picking up a copy for your group? the Orbit paperback of The Raven Scholar on Amazon.

Three spoiler-free questions to start the meeting

  1. What did you expect from a book that puts a murder investigation inside a contest for the throne? Which part of that premise drew you in first? How did it shape what you paid attention to in the opening pages?
  2. What would you test if you had to design a competition to choose Orrun’s next ruler? Give everyone a minute to name one quality a ruler needs. Then ask how a trial could measure it and how an ambitious contender might game the result.
  3. How did you react to the Raven’s voice the first time you heard it? Think about the confidence and humor in those opening pages. What did that voice make you willing to believe?

Spoiler warning. Questions 4–18 discuss the entire novel, including Gaida’s murder and the succession result. If your group needs a refresher on the final revelations, see The Raven Scholar ending explained.

Power and who deserves to rule Orrun

Hodgson has explained that Orrun’s system of succession arose in response to dynastic tyranny. That makes the Festival an attempt to solve a specific problem. As you discuss the trials, consider who gets to set the rules and who can afford to lose. Read Antonia Hodgson’s interview with The Fantasy Hive.

  1. Who really has a chance at the throne by the time the Festival begins? Consider who gets access to a monastery and a chance to become its champion. Where do family connections still matter under a system designed to interrupt dynastic rule?
  2. Would you trust Neema to govern Orrun? Name one moment when her habits as a scholar would serve her well as emperor. Then name a moment when those same habits might make her a poor choice.
  3. Why is Ruko’s reported vision enough for the judges to declare him the winner? Discuss what a vision of wearing the crown can tell the judges about how someone would govern. What is the most important thing they still have to take on trust?
  4. What does Havoc expect to gain by killing Gaida? Think about the position he’s offered in return for his loyalty. How much of the danger comes from Havoc’s willingness to act, and how much comes from a court that can make the bargain worth his while?
  5. At what point could someone still have stopped Andren from taking power? Point to a moment before or during the Festival and name who could have intervened. What would they have needed to know, and who would have had to believe them?

Loyalty, betrayal and the cost of obeying

  1. How do you divide responsibility for Yana’s exile between the people who ordered it, the brother who could intervene, and the scholar who wrote it down? Look at what Ruko and Neema each stood to lose. Where do you think the novel gives them a real choice?
  2. What made Neema’s decision about the exile order something Cain couldn’t overlook? Think about what he asked her to do and what it would have cost her to listen. What does each of them expect loyalty to demand in that moment?
  3. What does Yana want to save when she tries to keep Ruko from the throne? Consider how her concern for her brother fits alongside her knowledge of what he’s capable of. What would you look for in the text to tell whether she still trusts him?
  4. How do you judge Benna for using Dragonscale on Neema and making sure Gaida’s death would be investigated? Consider the two decisions separately. What alternatives were open to Benna, and who had to live with the risks she took?
  5. When Neema accepts Sol after refusing the Raven’s demand to kill Ruko, what kind of agreement does she think she’s making? Compare the terms she can set with what Cain learns about the Fox’s presence in his life. How much control would each person need for you to call the relationship a partnership?

The mystery, the ending and what comes next

  1. Which scene with Gaida reads differently once you know what she had discovered? Think back to her public humiliation of Neema. What did their rivalry encourage you to assume about her, and which parts of your first impression still hold up?
  2. What did you assume when the Blade of Peace was found with Gaida’s body? Once you know the poisoning and the stabbing were separate acts, revisit who wanted the death noticed and who benefited from silence. Which clue would you read most differently a second time?
  3. How much sympathy did you feel for Ruko when Andren took his appearance? Where did your group land on what Ruko owes Yana after what Andren does to him? Did anyone’s judgment change after hearing another reader’s answer?
  4. How seriously did you take Andren’s claim that imprisoning the Guardians would free humanity? Use the Raven’s demand of Neema to make the strongest case for his argument. Then use the purge to examine who gets to exercise power once the Guardians are bound.
  5. What does Tala’s rescue of Neema and Cain show about who can still act after the Festival? Compare that choice with one made by someone who holds an official position. Whose judgment would you trust to guide Orrun through the next crisis, and why?

A 45-minute book club plan

  • 5 minutes — Open with question 3. Ask everyone to describe the Raven’s voice in one word and explain what prompted it.
  • 10 minutes — Pair questions 4 and 6. Have the group identify one rule that shapes who gets to compete and one that shapes how the winner is chosen.
  • 15 minutes — Discuss questions 9 and 11 together. Ask everyone to name the choice they find hardest to defend and the pressure that makes it understandable.
  • 10 minutes — Use question 17. Ask someone to make the strongest case for Andren’s argument before the group weighs it against what he does with power.
  • 5 minutes — Hold a final vote on who should rule Orrun. Allow a vote to change the succession system itself. Ask each person for one scene that decided their vote.

Who did your group vote for, and which scene settled the debate? Share your pick in the comments.

For your next meeting, browse our book club discussion guides.

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook


Discover more from Books of Brilliance

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.