Why Memories Matter in The Giver by Lois Lowry

In Lois Lowry’s The Giver, Jonas notices something strange about an apple while tossing it with his friend Asher. For an instant, it changes. He takes it home to look more closely, but by then it looks ordinary again. Later, he learns that what he glimpsed was red. Lowry gives Jonas a small mystery before he has the words to ask the larger question. What else has his community taught him to live without?

Memories matter in The Giver because they let Jonas compare the life he knows with lives people once led. Once he has felt the thrill of a sled ride, the grief of war, and the warmth of a family gathering, he can judge what his community gained through Sameness and what it gave up. That judgment becomes urgent when Gabriel, the baby his family has been caring for, is scheduled for release.

Spoilers follow for major events in the novel.

Why the rules seem reasonable to Jonas

Before the Ceremony of Twelve, Jonas has good reason to trust the adults around him. They teach children to choose their words carefully, give families a nightly ritual for talking about their feelings, and assign jobs after years of watching what children do well. Even when Jonas takes the apple home and hears a public reminder about food, the incident seems like a small breach of manners. He has no idea that his fleeting glimpse of red matters more than the rule he broke.

That scene captures how Lowry makes the community convincing. Jonas knows how to apologize for taking the apple. He has no way to explain why he wanted a closer look. His training as Receiver of Memory finally gives him a vocabulary for an experience that his neighbors would struggle to imagine.

What the sled teaches Jonas about Sameness

The Giver’s first memory for Jonas is a sled ride down a snowy hill. Jonas feels the cold and the speed before he learns why his own community has no snow or hills. Weather once made growing food less predictable, and hills made transportation harder. The reasons are practical, which makes the scene more interesting. Jonas can understand why people wanted dependable harvests and still feel the loss of something as simple as a downhill ride.

Lowry returns to sledding in a later memory that leaves Jonas in terrible pain. The two rides make a harder case for keeping the past. If a sled ride could only bring joy, giving it up would be an easy mistake to spot. Because Jonas experiences both the pleasure and the danger, he has to decide whether safety is worth giving up the chance to have either experience.

Why the community keeps its memories with one person

The elders sometimes turn to the Receiver for advice because he can draw on experiences nobody else has. When they consider increasing the number of births, memories of hunger help him recognize what a food shortage could cost. Keeping those memories with one person allows everyone else to benefit from his judgment while he bears the pain of remembering.

Jonas sees the emotional cost of that arrangement after receiving a memory of a family celebrating together. He asks his parents whether they love him, and they correct his choice of words. The exchange is unsettling because his parents have spent his childhood teaching him to speak precisely. Here, the word they dismiss is the one he needs to describe something he has finally felt.

What the release recording makes Jonas responsible for

Jonas’s father speaks gently while he gives a newborn twin a lethal injection. Watching the recording, Jonas has to make sense of two facts at once. His father sounds like the nurturing adult he knows, and he is killing a child. The community’s word for the procedure, release, has allowed Jonas to hear people discuss it without understanding what they were doing.

Gabriel turns that realization into a decision. Jonas and the Giver already have a plan for Jonas to leave, which would return the memories he carries to the community. When Jonas learns that Gabriel is due to be released the next morning, he leaves ahead of schedule and takes the baby with him. By that point, knowing what release means changes what Jonas is willing to let happen.

On a reread, the apple is the scene I’d bring back to the group after discussing the recording. Jonas wants someone else to see the change he saw. By the time he leaves with Gabriel, the stakes of that wish have changed. If the people he grew up with could see what he sees, what would they be willing to do about it?

Five book club questions about memory in The Giver

1. What does the apple scene reveal about Jonas before he understands that he’s seeing red? How does Asher’s reaction shape what Jonas does next?
2. Which of the two sled memories makes the stronger case for Sameness? Would your answer change if the decision affected your own family?
3. Why do Jonas’s parents correct him when he asks if they love him? What does their answer tell you about what they understand by care?
4. How much responsibility does Jonas’s father bear for the twin’s death? What evidence in the recording shapes your answer?
5. How does taking Gabriel change Jonas’s original plan with the Giver? What does Jonas now owe to Gabriel and to the people he leaves behind?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Rereading for book club? Find Lois Lowry’s The Giver in paperback on Amazon.

Keep reading. The Books of Brilliance review of The Giver · The Giver ending explained · The Giver Quartet in reading order

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook