The Secret History Ending Explained: Why Richard Dreams of Bunny

Spoiler warning: This article discusses both deaths and the final scene of Donna Tartt’s The Secret History.

Richard Papen dreams of Bunny Corcoran because Bunny’s murder leaves him with a responsibility he spends much of the novel trying to keep at a distance. In the nightmare, Bunny’s body lies at the bottom of a bathtub, and Richard’s first impulse is to hide it. The novel’s final dream features Henry Winter. Read together, the two scenes show what Richard fears facing and whose approval he still seems to want.

What happens at the end of The Secret History?

The group’s secret begins to unravel when Julian receives a letter Bunny wrote before his death. Bunny describes the killing at the bacchanal and says he fears Henry. Julian initially doubts the letter, then recognizes the hotel stationery from Rome. He leaves Hampden without going to the authorities.

The final confrontation takes place in a hotel room. Charles arrives with a gun and shoots Richard during the struggle. Henry kisses Camilla, then shoots himself. Richard survives, and the surviving members of the group drift apart. In the epilogue, Richard asks Camilla to marry him, but she tells him she still loves Henry. Richard’s last encounter with Henry comes in a dream.

Why does Richard dream of Bunny in a bathtub?

Bunny was killed at a ravine. The nightmare moves his body somewhere small and ordinary, where Richard can see his face through the water. When Richard hears people approaching, he tries to pull Bunny out so he can hide the body. That detail gives the nightmare its force. Even in a scene his own mind has invented, Richard’s instinct is to keep anyone from seeing what happened.

Richard was present when Henry pushed Bunny. The dream makes Richard handle the evidence himself. He wakes physically sick and in tears, then takes a bath and manages to feel more like himself again. That sequence makes guilt an incomplete answer on its own. Richard feels the horror of what they did, but the habit of burying it kicks in almost as quickly. He can recoil from the murder and still protect the people who committed it, including himself.

Why does Richard dream of Henry at the very end?

In the final dream, Richard encounters Henry in a strange museum. He asks whether Henry is happy where he is. Henry admits he isn’t especially happy and turns the question back on Richard. The exchange is brief, but the direction of the question matters. Richard wants to know what became of Henry. Henry makes him consider what has become of him.

The museum also feels like a fitting place for Richard to find the person he once admired. At Hampden, he wanted entry into a world that seemed more beautiful and interesting than his own. In the dream, the museum offers images of distant landmarks. Richard can look at those places without going anywhere. Years after leaving Hampden, he can still revisit that year in exquisite detail, but the dream gives little sense that revisiting it has helped him build a life he wants.

What the two dreams reveal about Richard

The difference that sticks with me is how much room Richard gives each man to speak. Bunny’s mouth fills with water while Richard tries to move his body. Henry gets a conversation and the last word between them. Bunny’s letter briefly reverses that imbalance. In it, he gets to say that he was frightened and name the person he feared. His account cuts through the version of events in which the group treats him as a problem to solve.

The final dream still gives Henry the role he held for much of the novel. Richard looks to him for an answer. What he gets is a plain observation about his own unhappiness. Go back to the prologue after reading it and notice how quickly Richard tells us Bunny was dead. By the end, the harder admission is how much of Richard’s life still revolves around the people who killed him.

For more on the novel’s setup and whether it’s worth a reread, see our review of Donna Tartt’s The Secret History.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

If you want to reread the bathtub nightmare alongside the epilogue, find the Vintage paperback of The Secret History on Amazon.

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook