The Night Watchman by Louise Erdrich Review, A Powerful Pulitzer Prize Winning Historical Novel

Today, we will be reviewing The Night Watchman by Louise Erdrich, a Pulitzer Prize winning historical novel that deserves every bit of praise it has received. Keep reading to find out what we thought of this novel and whether you should add it to your reading list!

The Night Watchman Summary

The Night Watchman follows Thomas Wazhashk, a night watchman working at the jewel bearing plant in Turtle Mountain during the 1950’s. But Thomas is more than just a factory worker. He is also an Ojibwe council member fighting against a dangerous termination bill proposed by Senator Arthur Vivian Watkins. The bill threatens Native American tribes by terminating their recognized status and relocating them away from their land and communities.

Thomas spends his nights working long shifts at the plant while also organizing meetings, writing letters, and trying to rally support against the government’s plans. He understands what is at stake and refuses to stand by while his people face losing their homes, traditions, and identity.

Alongside Thomas is Patrice Paranteau, his determined niece who also works at the jewel bearing plant. Patrice is one of the strongest characters in the novel and quickly became one of my favorites. She helps support her family financially while dealing with the emotional burden of her missing sister Vera.

After hearing troubling rumors and receiving little information about Vera’s whereabouts, Patrice decides to travel to Minneapolis to find her. The journey is frightening and unfamiliar, especially since she has never left home before. Still, she pushes forward because she refuses to abandon her sister.

The novel balances both Thomas and Patrice’s stories beautifully while also introducing readers to many memorable side characters living in Turtle Mountain. Their lives intertwine in ways that make the community feel real and alive throughout the entire novel.

Commentary

The Night Watchman was released in 2020 and later won the 2021 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. After finishing the novel, it becomes very easy to understand why it received such recognition.

Louise Erdrich based Thomas on her grandfather, Patrick Gourneau, who actually fought against the government’s termination efforts. Erdrich used letters written by her grandfather as inspiration for many parts of the story, which gives the novel an incredible sense of authenticity and emotional weight.

One of the best aspects of this novel is how grounded it feels. The story never feels overly dramatized or exaggerated. Instead, Erdrich focuses on the daily lives of the people living in Turtle Mountain and shows readers the struggles, joys, fears, and relationships that shape the community.

While Thomas and Patrice are technically the main protagonists, this book feels much larger than just their individual stories. Erdrich allows many different characters to shine throughout the novel and every single one feels important in some way. Turtle Mountain itself almost becomes a character because of how vividly Erdrich describes the setting and the people living there.

That is something I appreciated while reading this novel. The community feels alive. You can picture the factory shifts, the meetings, the conversations between family members, and the long cold nights Thomas spends working as the night watchman. The attention to detail is incredible and it helps immerse you into the world of the novel.

I also loved how Erdrich handled the historical aspects of the story. Before reading this book, I was not fully aware of the termination policies that targeted Native American tribes during the 1950’s. The novel does an amazing job of educating readers without ever feeling like a history lecture.

Instead of simply presenting facts, Erdrich shows the emotional and cultural consequences these policies had on Native communities. You understand why Thomas fights so hard against the bill because you see how important Turtle Mountain is to the people living there.

Patrice’s storyline was equally compelling. Her search for Vera adds tension and emotional urgency to the novel. Some of the scenes in Minneapolis are incredibly heartbreaking because they reveal how vulnerable Native women were during that time period.

Patrice is an unforgettable character because of how resilient she is. She carries so much responsibility on her shoulders and continues moving forward despite the fear and uncertainty surrounding her. I found myself constantly rooting for her throughout the novel.

Another thing I really appreciated was Erdrich’s writing style. The prose is beautiful without becoming difficult to read. Some literary fiction novels can feel overly complicated or slow, but The Night Watchman remains engaging from beginning to end.

There are moments in the book that may initially seem small or disconnected from the larger story. At times, you may even wonder why certain scenes are included. But by the end of the novel, you begin to understand how every moment contributes to the larger picture Erdrich is painting.

This is a story about survival, community, family, identity, and resistance. It captures both the ordinary and extraordinary moments in people’s lives. That balance is one of the reasons the novel works so well.

I also found myself surprisingly interested in Minneapolis after reading this novel. Erdrich describes the city in a way that makes it feel vivid and memorable. Even though much of the novel focuses on Turtle Mountain, the contrast between the reservation and the city adds another layer to the story.

The storytelling and attention to detail showcase exactly why this novel won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. Louise Erdrich created something that feels deeply personal while also telling an important historical story that deserves more attention.

Final Thoughts

Overall, The Night Watchman is an outstanding historical novel that combines powerful storytelling with fascinating history and unforgettable characters. Louise Erdrich writes with compassion and authenticity, making the novel both emotionally impactful and incredibly immersive.

I enjoyed every second of this book and will definitely be checking out more of Erdrich’s work in the future. If you enjoy historical fiction, literary fiction, character driven stories, or novels centered around communities and family, then this is absolutely a book you should read.

It is rare to find a novel that feels both intimate and expansive at the same time, but The Night Watchman accomplishes exactly that.

I highly recommend adding this Pulitzer Prize winning novel to your reading list. Until next time, happy reading!

Commentary

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook