The Five Best Mystery Books of All Time 

Reading a great mystery novel while sipping your tea is a great feeling. But only if the book you are reading is a good one. We decided to list the five best mystery books of all time to see which books are the best of the best. 

The Five Best Mystery Books of All Time
The Five Best Mystery Books of All Time

It is never easy to make a shortened list like this but that also makes it fun. Choosing only five is going to leave many great books off the list. You can see the full list of the best mystery books here. You can see the five books selected below. 

The Five Best Mystery Books of All Time 


Agatha Christie has a ton of great books and you can most of her books and nobody would really argue. We opted to go with Murder on the Orient Express as it is an iconic book that had a lot of twists and turns. The other author that deserves a spot on this list is Arthur Conan Doyle and his novel The Hound of the Baskervilles. It is a classic work and one of the best detective novels ever written. 

The three other books to make the list are great mystery books that we enjoyed a lot. We know that many people will contest these selections and insert their favorite mystery books and that is fine. Everyone has different preferences. But as a lover of mystery novels, these books are must reads that most people would say they enjoyed.  


What did you think of out five best mystery books of all-time list? What books should have made the list? Let us know in the comments below. Until next time, happy reading!

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook

18 thoughts on “The Five Best Mystery Books of All Time 

  1. laynepartin says:

    I would add The Cabinet of Curiosities by Douglas Preston and Lincoln Child. I also think that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle s A Study in Scarlet is almost as good as Hound of the Baskervilles

  2. rainbowman56 says:

    The Secret History is an awfully boring and dull pretentious drivel. Scrap it and put Dostoevskij Crime and Punishment in its place

  3. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    I think Conan Doyle was much better writing short stories than novels; so if you like Sherlock Holmes go for “The Adventures of S.H.” and “The Memoirs of S.H.” Then you can go to Chesterton’s Father Brown and I hope you’ll be delighted.

  4. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    But I do agree that the best novel by Doyle is “The Hound of…”.

  5. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    Why have you deleted my various Top Fives???

    1. Ahaqir says:

      I can assure you I haven’t deleted anything. Either it was WordPress or something weird happened. You are welcome to submit your own top five as an article as a guest post if you want to 🙂

      1. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

        Well sorry. Then I really don’t know what has happened.

  6. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    This six books are (today!!) my TOP 5 in no particular order :
    Gaston Leroux The Yellow Room Mystery
    Patricia Highsmith The Talented Mr. Ripley
    Carter Dickson The Judas Window
    Elizabeth George A Traitor to Memory
    Anthony Berkeley The Poisoned Chocolates Case
    Francis Iles Malice Aforethought

    1. Anonymous says:

      Thank you for these suggestions. I have noted them down. Do you like Martha Grimes and P.D. James?

  7. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    Oooh Ahaqir sorry. I also don’t understand what happened !!!

  8. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    Of course Francis Iles is Anthony Berkeley in disguise.

  9. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    If you like your mysteries more hard boiled you can delete the Elizabeth George novel and add Dashiell Hammett’s The Glass Key.

  10. Cesar Esteban Diaz Diaz says:

    Today I would delete the Gaston Leroux novel and would add
    ELLERY QUEEN’s The Greek Coffin Mystery.


Leave a Reply