If you’ve never read a Miss Marple short story, start with “The Tuesday Night Club.” It was Jane Marple’s first appearance in print, and it introduces her in the middle of a conversation about a dinner that left one guest dead. Read “The Thumb Mark of St. Peter” next to hear Marple tell a case of her own, then try “The Blue Geranium” for a mystery that starts with a warning about flowers. All three appear in Agatha Christie’s 1932 collection The Thirteen Problems.
What I like about a good Christie mystery is the moment when a detail everyone has heard starts to mean something different. Miss Marple gets there by paying attention to how people behave. Someone in St Mary Mead may have done something similar for a very ordinary reason, and that resemblance gives her a question nobody else thought to ask. These three stories give you a chance to try that approach yourself.
| If you’re in the mood for… | Read this |
|---|---|
| A dinner-table whodunit and Marple’s debut | “The Tuesday Night Club” |
| A family mystery with a puzzling last remark | “The Thumb Mark of St. Peter” |
| An eerie prediction and a memorable visual clue | “The Blue Geranium” |
1. “The Tuesday Night Club” for Miss Marple’s debut

At a gathering in Miss Marple’s home, Sir Henry Clithering tells the group about a dinner at which three people were poisoned. Only one died. The people in the room have the same account to work from, and each gets a chance to make sense of it. First published in 1927, the story opens the collection and shows how the club’s game works.
The pleasure here is watching the other guests decide which details matter while Marple quietly makes up her own mind. If you like to guess along, pause before she gives her answer. Pick one detail you think the group has passed over too quickly. Even if you guess the culprit, see whether you can explain why only one person died.
Find The Tuesday Night Club on Amazon!
2. “The Thumb Mark of St. Peter” for a case Marple tells herself

When Mabel’s husband dies suddenly, village gossip turns on her. Mabel is Miss Marple’s niece, and Marple tells the club how she looked into the death. There’s a possible poisoning and a dying remark that makes very little sense as reported.
Hearing Marple tell her own story changes the feel of the club meeting. She knows what it means for Mabel to have the village settle on an explanation before anyone can prove it. The reading game here is to keep track of who actually heard or saw something and who is repeating what somebody else said. That distinction makes the strange remark worth a second look.
Find The Thumb Mark of St. Peter on Amazon!
3. “The Blue Geranium” for a mystery with a ghost-story feel

Mrs. Pritchard receives a psychic’s warning involving blue flowers. A blue primrose is a warning, a blue hollyhock signals danger, and a blue geranium foretells death. When Mrs. Pritchard dies suddenly, the prediction makes the events seem to fit together.
Christie makes it easy to get caught up in what the flowers are supposed to mean. A more productive question is what, exactly, someone in the house could have seen. If you like a mystery with a single image you can keep turning over in your head, the blue geranium is reason enough to choose this one first.
Find The Blue Geranium on Amazon!
Which edition should you look for?
The Thirteen Problems contains 13 stories. The collection was also published in the United States as The Tuesday Club Murders. If you spot the name The Solving Six, that’s a U.S. title for the individual story “The Tuesday Night Club.” When borrowing or buying a copy, check the contents for all three stories above.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
You can go straight to “The Tuesday Night Club.” If these three cases make you want more, go back to the start of the collection and read the others in book order. That gives you more time with the club and lets you hear each storyteller’s idea of what makes a mystery difficult. For a full-length case, my pick is 4.50 from Paddington. It begins with a woman who sees a murder through the window of another train.
Follow us on Instagram and Facebook
Posts
Discover more from Books of Brilliance
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






I love Miss Marple!