This guide discusses the novel’s premise and leaves the ending unspoiled.

Stephen Graham Jones’s The Buffalo Hunter Hunter draws on two episodes in Blackfeet history. On January 23, 1870, U.S. troops attacked Chief Heavy Runner’s winter camp on the Marias River. By the winter of 1883–84, the near-disappearance of the buffalo and inadequate government rations had brought famine to the Blackfeet reservation. Jones uses a fictional vampire to carry the reader from one event to the other.

What happened at the Marias Massacre?

Before dawn on January 23, 1870, soldiers under Major Eugene Baker reached Heavy Runner’s camp on the Marias, also known to the Blackfeet as Bear Creek. Baker’s orders originally called for an attack on Mountain Chief’s band and specified that Heavy Runner’s camp should be spared. Army guide Joe Kipp later said he told Baker whose camp it was before the attack. Heavy Runner came forward carrying papers that attested to his peaceful relations with the United States. The soldiers shot him. Many of the people killed were women, children, and elders. Troops burned lodges and supplies and took horses, leaving survivors to face the winter with fewer ways to shelter or feed themselves.

Readers may see two death tolls. Baker reported 173 killed. Kipp said he counted 217, the figure Saga Press uses in its description of the book. The disagreement also concerned who was killed. Baker categorized most of the dead as warriors or able-bodied men. Testimony from people who witnessed the attack describes a camp largely made up of noncombatants, with many of its hunters away.

Was Good Stab a real person?

There was a historical Good Stab, also known as Yellow Owl. Henderson identifies him as the husband of Buffalo Trail Woman and records that soldiers killed him during the attack. Buffalo Trail Woman survived with wounds and was among the people whose testimony helped document the massacre. Jones’s Good Stab, the vampire who recounts his life to a Lutheran pastor in 1912, is a fictional character. The shared name is a historical connection readers can trace. Whether Jones drew it directly from Yellow Owl is unconfirmed. Arthur Beaucarne and the diary that structures the novel are also part of the fiction. Henderson’s account of Buffalo Trail Woman and Good Stab · Jones on writing the three narrators

What was the Blackfeet Starvation Winter?

By 1883, the great bison herds of the northern Plains had nearly disappeared. Commercial hunters supplied a market for hides that railroads helped expand. The loss was especially devastating for the Blackfeet, whose relationship with the buffalo included food, clothing, shelter, and ceremony. As the herds vanished, families faced the winter of 1883–84 with inadequate provisions. In August 1884, the Blackfeet Agency’s federal agent wrote that the government’s flour estimate had covered only a third of what was required and that its beef purchase provided less than half a ration.

The title makes more sense with that history in view. Good Stab hunts the people who hunt the buffalo. His own appetite also changes his body, giving survival a cost he can see in himself. In an interview with KRWG Public Media, Jones connected the book’s pursuit of the hunters to the destruction of the herds and the pressure on Plains peoples to move onto reservations. The famine helps explain why the disappearance of the buffalo carries as much weight in the novel as the violence of a single morning.

How Blackfeet survivors kept the history alive

Spear Woman was a child when she survived the attack. Her daughter Katie Upham Croff later shared her account with a newspaper. Bear Head, Heavy Runner’s nephew, gave a sworn statement and also recorded scenes from the massacre on a painted robe. In the 1930s, Blackfeet artist George Bull Child used several survivors’ accounts to create his own painted record of the attack. Blackfeet Community College has carried that work of remembrance forward through its annual Bear River commemoration.

Jones gives his novel the shape of a recovered diary, with a pastor writing down what Good Stab tells him. The survivor accounts offer a history of how knowledge actually traveled after the massacre. It passed from parents to children, into sworn testimony, and onto painted hides. Reading those accounts alongside the novel makes the book’s choice of narrator feel more consequential. Every time Arthur puts Good Stab’s words on the page, someone else is deciding how his story will reach a future reader.

Read our spoiler-light review of The Buffalo Hunter Hunter.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

See the Saga Press hardcover of The Buffalo Hunter Hunter.

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook


Discover more from Books of Brilliance

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.