7 Christmas Mysteries for Readers Who Want a Whodunit With Their Holiday Reading

A Christmas gathering gives a mystery writer an excuse to put people who’ve been avoiding one another all year under the same roof. Add a family inheritance, a snowstorm, or a holiday performance that everyone insists must go ahead, and you have a good reason for the suspects to stay put while the detective asks questions.

For a classic locked-room mystery, start with Agatha Christie’s Hercule Poirot’s Christmas. If you like studying the evidence yourself, pick Janice Hallett’s The Christmas Appeal. And if your ideal December read begins with a stalled train and a house that feels wrong the moment you step inside, go straight to Mystery in White.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

1. Hercule Poirot’s Christmas by Agatha Christie

Simeon Lee summons his family for Christmas, and on Christmas Eve he’s found murdered behind a locked door. Poirot has two puzzles to untangle. How did the killer get out, and which of the people who resented Lee had a reason to act that night? The violence is sharper than the festive title suggests, even by the standards of a country-house murder.

This is the first pick if you like a mystery that asks you to reconsider what witnesses heard and what they assumed those sounds meant. You can jump straight into this case. If you’re shopping for an older U.S. edition, you may see the same book titled Murder for Christmas or A Holiday for Murder.

Find Hercule Poirot’s Christmas on Amazon

2. The Santa Klaus Murder by Mavis Doriel Hay

On Christmas Day at Flaxmere, the Melbury family’s country house, a guest dressed as Santa discovers the body of patriarch Sir Osmond Melbury. The person in the costume appears to have had an opportunity to commit the murder, but plenty of other people stand to benefit from Sir Osmond’s death.

The fun here is weighing motive against opportunity. A suspect with a clear reason to want Sir Osmond dead can look much less convincing once you ask where they were. Pick this one if your favorite part of a holiday mystery is drawing up a suspect list and watching the order change.

Browse Mavis Doriel Hay’s The Santa Klaus Murder on Amazon

3. Mystery in White by J. Jefferson Farjeon

A Christmas Eve train stalls in a snowstorm, and a group of passengers ventures out in search of shelter. The country house they find has a fire going and tea laid out, but nobody is there to welcome them. It’s the sort of opening that makes a small domestic detail feel like evidence. Sourcebooks edition

Of the three Golden Age picks here, this is the one I’d suggest to a reader who likes a little unease with their clues. The strangers have to work out what happened inside the house while deciding how much they can trust the people they arrived with.

Look up Mystery in White on Amazon

4. The Christmas Appeal by Janice Hallett

The Fairway Players are staging Jack and the Beanstalk to raise money for a church roof. Their production leaves behind a trail of emails and messages, along with a dead body. Two lawyers sift through the record, and you get to read the correspondence alongside them.

Read this novella if you like spotting the difference between what people say in a group email and what they admit in private. The format makes it easy to read a few exchanges at a time, though the little contradictions make it tempting to keep going. Start with The Appeal if you’d like to meet the Fairway Players in publication order.

Find The Christmas Appeal on Amazon

5. Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret by Benjamin Stevenson

A magician’s Christmas show goes horribly wrong, and Ernest Cunningham finds himself investigating two crimes. Stevenson builds the short mystery around an Advent calendar of clues, giving readers regular chances to stop and make a guess.

This is the pick for readers who enjoy a narrator who knows they’re trying to beat him to the answer. The stage-magic setting makes that relationship especially fun. Every time a feat seems impossible, you have to consider where you were being encouraged to look. It’s a holiday entry in the Ernest Cunningham series, which begins with Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone.

Browse Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret on Amazon

6. The Christmas Murder Game by Alexandra Benedict

Lily Armitage returns to Endgame House to compete with her cousins in the family’s Christmas game. The contest runs across the twelve days of Christmas, with twelve clues leading to twelve keys. The prize is the family home, but Lily has her own reason to play. The clues might also reveal who killed her mother.

Pick this if you like solving riddles on the page. The contest gives you a concrete problem to work on while the larger mystery simmers, and the same clues can mean very different things to Lily and to a cousin who just wants the house.

Find The Christmas Murder Game on Amazon

7. I Am Half-Sick of Shadows by Alan Bradley

A film crew arrives at Buckshaw, where young Flavia de Luce has plans to catch Father Christmas. Then an actress is found dead and a snowstorm strands the people who’ve gathered at the estate. The setup gives Flavia an unusually crowded house to investigate, and her curiosity about how things work makes her a lively guide through it.

Choose this one if the detective’s personality matters as much to you as the solution. It’s the fourth Flavia novel, so readers who want the family story from the beginning can start with The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie. Flavia de Luce reading order

Look up I Am Half-Sick of Shadows on Amazon

For more seasonal reading across genres, see The Best Christmas Books to Read. If you’d rather spend the evening solving a set of short logic puzzles, our Murdle guide explains where Merry Murdle fits.

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook