Romance isn’t usually the first shelf I head toward. Fantasy is my favorite genre, and I’m often drawn to historical fiction, mysteries, and science fiction. But enjoying those books doesn’t mean a love story can’t offer the same things I look for elsewhere: memorable characters, a compelling setting, sharp dialogue, and a reason to keep turning the pages.
The best romance novels for readers who don’t usually read romance give you a familiar way into the genre. That might be a magical house, a time-slip mystery, a publishing-world rivalry, or the social observations of a classic novel.
These ten books offer different starting points. The selections prioritize distinctive premises, interests beyond the central relationship, and a satisfying romantic arc. They include contemporary romances, romantic fantasy, and one classic courtship novel. The order is a reading menu rather than a ranking, and the recommendations below explain both the appeal and the potential mismatch.
1. Book Lovers by Emily Henry
Best for: Readers who enjoy sharp dialogue, books about books, and family relationships.
In Emily Henry’s Book Lovers, literary agent Nora Stephens travels to a small town with her sister, Libby, and keeps encountering editor Charlie Lastra. Nora is ambitious, protective, and very aware that she doesn’t fit the usual small-town romantic heroine mold.
That self-awareness makes this an appealing place to start if familiar romance setups sometimes put you off. Henry uses the setup to question the idea that a successful woman needs to abandon her career or become a different person to deserve love.
The sister relationship also gives the story a second emotional center. If you usually choose fiction about complicated family bonds, there is a familiar interest here alongside the romance.
Consider another pick if: You want the relationship to take a back seat. This is firmly a romance, with on-page sexual content.
2. The Seven Year Slip by Ashley Poston
Best for: Readers who love time travel, impossible situations, and stories about starting over.
The premise of Ashley Poston’s The Seven Year Slip is immediately intriguing: book publicist Clementine encounters a man in her late aunt’s apartment, but he belongs to a time seven years before her own.
That temporal gap makes timing a literal obstacle. It also raises a question that can draw in readers of speculative fiction: how much can someone change between the person you meet and the person they eventually become?
The book combines its magical premise with grief, professional ambition, and uncertainty about the future. For someone drawn to time-travel stories, it offers an accessible bridge into romance without requiring a long series or an elaborate fictional world.
Consider another pick if: You want rigorous science-fiction explanations. The time slip works as a magical device, and loss is an important part of the story.
3. The Flatshare by Beth O’Leary
Best for: Readers who enjoy unusual storytelling setups and everyday-life fiction.
As Beth O’Leary’s description of The Flatshare explains, Tiffy and Leon share an apartment and a bed without initially meeting. Leon uses the flat during the day while Tiffy is at work; she uses it when he is away working nights.
Their arrangement provides a practical reason for their lives to overlap before a conventional courtship can begin. Notes left around the apartment allow a connection to develop through small exchanges rather than an immediate declaration of attraction.
Housing costs, work, friendship, and family troubles give the premise a life beyond its romantic possibilities. This is a good option if you prefer characters whose relationship develops alongside the ordinary demands of adulthood.
Consider another pick if: You want uncomplicated comfort reading. The story includes an emotionally abusive past relationship and a wrongful-imprisonment subplot.
4. Seven Days in June by Tia Williams
Best for: Readers of contemporary literary fiction and emotionally complicated family stories.
In Tia Williams’s Seven Days in June, writers Eva Mercy and Shane Hall reconnect at a literary event. Years earlier, they shared an intense teenage relationship, and their books have carried traces of that connection ever since.
Their reunion involves more than rekindling an attraction. Eva is a mother with a career and responsibilities, while their shared history brings difficult experiences into the present.
The novel’s attention to Black creative life, motherhood, chronic pain, and personal history makes it a useful starting point for readers who want a romance rooted in a wider social world. Choose it when you want emotional weight alongside the possibility of a second chance.
Consider another pick if: You want a light diversion. Addiction and trauma are part of the story, and it contains explicit sexual content.
5. The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy by Megan Bannen
Best for: Fantasy readers who enjoy strange worlds, dark humor, and unlikely connections.
In Megan Bannen’s The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy, Hart is a marshal patrolling magical Tanria, while Mercy is struggling to keep her family’s undertaking business running. Their abrasive encounters contrast with a growing connection through anonymous letters.
For a reader whose favorite genre is fantasy, the setting supplies a strong reason to give the romance a chance. The combination of magical dangers, funeral work, and small-town concerns makes this a particularly distinctive entry on the list.
The correspondence also creates an appealing tension between how people present themselves in person and what they reveal when they feel safe enough to be honest.
Consider another pick if: You want epic military fantasy or extensive political intrigue. The relationship drives the novel, which also includes death, macabre material, and on-page sex.
6. The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna
Best for: Cozy-fantasy readers and anyone drawn to found-family stories.
In Sangu Mandanna’s The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, Mika Moon takes a job teaching three young witches at Nowhere House. There, she encounters an unconventional household and a guarded librarian named Jamie.
The appeal for a fantasy reader is easy to identify: magic, secrets, and a home full of people who need one another. The romantic relationship develops within that larger story of belonging.
This would be one of my first starting-point suggestions for someone who wants warmth and an inviting magical setting. It offers the community appeal associated with cozy fantasy while giving romantic connection an important role.
Consider another pick if: You want danger and relentless plot twists. The tone is largely comforting, though the novel includes loss, childhood mistreatment, and some on-page sexual content.
7. The Love Hypothesis by Ali Hazelwood
Best for: Readers who like academic settings, career pressures, and romantic comedy.
In Ali Hazelwood’s The Love Hypothesis, Ph.D. candidate Olive Smith ends up in a fake relationship with professor Adam Carlsen after an impulsive attempt to convince her friend that she is dating someone.
The academic setting gives the characters concerns beyond whether their arrangement will become real. Research, professional credibility, and the pressures facing a young scientist provide another point of entry.
This is also a useful choice if you want to sample a recognizable romance convention. Fake dating lets the reader anticipate complications while watching the characters struggle to distinguish performance from genuine feeling.
Consider another pick if: You dislike academic power imbalances or contrived romantic setups. The book includes sexual harassment and explicit sexual content.
8. The Kiss Quotient by Helen Hoang
Best for: Readers who prioritize character development and vulnerable conversations.
In Helen Hoang’s The Kiss Quotient, autistic econometrician Stella Lane hires escort Michael Phan to help her gain experience with physical intimacy. Their arrangement becomes more emotionally complicated than either expects.
The reason to choose this book is its character-focused premise: a person who approaches one part of life with confidence tries to navigate another part that feels much less predictable.
It offers a direct introduction to romance centered on intimacy, communication, and self-acceptance. Being new to romance does not necessarily mean wanting minimal sexual content, and this selection suits readers interested in that aspect of the genre.
Consider another pick if: You prefer sex to remain off-page. Physical intimacy is central to the premise, and the sexual content is explicit.
9. Get a Life, Chloe Brown by Talia Hibbert
Best for: Readers who enjoy funny, character-led stories about rebuilding a life.
As Talia Hibbert’s introduction to Get a Life, Chloe Brown explains, chronically ill Chloe creates a list of experiences she wants to pursue after a near-death experience. She enlists handyman and artist Red Morgan to help her venture beyond familiar routines.
The list gives the story a clear purpose alongside the developing relationship. Chloe wants to make changes in her own life, which makes this an appealing option for readers drawn to personal-growth narratives.
It also offers humor without requiring the characters’ difficulties to disappear. Chronic illness, emotional vulnerability, and the work of learning to trust someone give the romantic setup substance.
Consider another pick if: You want a romance with very little sexual content. This is an explicit contemporary romance, and past relationship abuse is part of its emotional background.
10. Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
Best for: Readers of classics, historical settings, and social satire.
In Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy must reconsider their judgments of each other within a society shaped by money, status, reputation, and marriage.
It belongs here as a classic courtship novel rather than a contemporary genre romance. The relationship is central, but Austen’s observations about families, social behavior, and economic security offer plenty for readers whose usual interests lie elsewhere.
This is a particularly good starting point if your objection to romance is that you expect attraction to replace character development. Elizabeth and Darcy’s changing understanding of each other gives the love story its force.
Consider another pick if: You want modern pacing and language. There is no explicit sexual content, but the prose and social conventions ask for a different reading rhythm.
Which Romance Novel Should You Try First?
Choose according to what already keeps you reading. For fantasy, start with The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witchesfor warmth or The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy for a stranger, more macabre world. For time travel, choose The Seven Year Slip. For contemporary fiction with heavier emotional stakes, try Seven Days in June.
If you simply want an accessible contemporary starting point, Book Lovers offers a familiar world of books, work, and family. If you prefer classics and want to avoid explicit sexual content, Pride and Prejudice is the clearest choice here.
You don’t need to become a devoted romance reader to find a book you enjoy. Start with the kind of story you already like, and let the relationship give you another reason to care about the characters.
Which romance novel would you recommend to someone who rarely reads the genre? Share your pick in the comments.
**If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you**
Follow us on Instagram and Facebook
Discover more from Books of Brilliance
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
